Complex Claims Consultant - Lawyers Professional Liability (Large Law)

CNA Insurance
Princeton, NJ

You have a clear vision of where your career can go. And we have the leadership to help you get there. At CNA, we strive to create a culture in which people know they matter and are part of something important, ensuring the abilities of all employees are used to their fullest potential. CNA is the market leader in providing Lawyers liability coverage and provides best-in-class claim service. We are seeking a dynamic self-starter to join our team as a Complex Claims Consultant focused on Large Law claims ranging from mid-sized practices to multinational law firms across the globe.

This Complex Claims Consultant will play a critical role in managing and resolving complex legal malpractice claims by evaluating coverage, assessing liability and damages, setting timely reserves, negotiating and settling claims, and directing litigation. At CNA, Claims Professionals use their specialized expertise to handle claims efficiently and seamlessly in a collaborative environment focused on continuous improvement. The individual in this role will collaborate in a rich team environment including claim leadership and business partners to ensure the best possible outcome on every claim.

Claims are handled on an account basis and involve primary, excess and quota share policies and towers. Recognized as a technical expert in the interpretation of complex or unusual policy coverages in area of expertise. Under general management direction, works within assigned limits of broad authority on assignments requiring a high degree of technical complexity and coordination. May have regional, industry segment or company-wide scope of responsibility within specialty area.

The claim professional will handle approximately 150 pending Large Law claims.

This position enjoys a flexible, hybrid work schedule from one of the listed CNA office locations.

JOB DESCRIPTION:

Essential Duties & Responsibilities

Performs a combination of duties in accordance with departmental guidelines:

  • Manages an inventory of highly complex professional liability claims, with exposures that require a high degree of specialized technical expertise and coordination, by following company protocols to verify policy coverage, conduct investigations, develop and employ resolution strategies, and authorize disbursements within authority limits.
  • Ensures exceptional customer service by managing all aspects of the claim, interacting professionally and effectively, achieving quality and cycle time standards, providing timely updates and responding promptly to inquiries and requests for information.
  • Verifies coverage and establishes timely and adequate reserves by reviewing and interpreting policy language and partnering with coverage counsel on more complex matters, estimating potential claim valuation, and following company's claim handling protocols.
  • Leads focused investigation to determine compensability, liability and covered damages by gathering pertinent information, such as contracts or other documents, taking recorded statements from customers, claimants, injured workers, witnesses, and working with experts, or other parties, as necessary to verify the facts of the claim.
  • Resolves claims by collaborating with internal and external business partners to develop, own and execute a claim resolution strategy, that includes management of timely and adequate reserves, collaborating with coverage experts, negotiating complex settlements, partnering with counsel to manage complex litigation and authorizing payments within scope of authority.
  • Establishes and manages claim budgets by achieving timely claim resolution, selecting and actively overseeing appropriate resources, authorizing expense payments and delivering high quality service in an efficient manner.
  • Realizes and addresses subrogation/salvage opportunities or potential fraud occurrences by evaluating the facts of the claim and making referrals to appropriate Claim, Recovery or SIU resources for further investigation.
  • Achieves quality standards by appropriately managing each claim to ensure that all company protocols are followed, work is accurate and timely, all files are properly documented and claims are resolved and paid timely.
  • Keeps senior leadership informed of significant risks and losses by completing loss summaries, identifying claims to include on oversight/watch lists, and preparing and presenting succinct summaries to senior management.
  • Maintains subject matter expertise and ensures compliance with state/local regulatory requirements by following company guidelines, and staying current on commercial insurance laws, regulations or trends for line of business.
  • Mentors, guides, develops and delivers training to less experienced Claim Professionals.

May perform additional duties as assigned.

Reporting Relationship

Typically Director or above


Skills, Knowledge & Abilities

  • Thorough knowledge of the commercial insurance industry, products, policy language, coverage, and claim practices.
  • Strong communication and presentation skills both verbal and written, including the ability to communicate business and technical information clearly.
  • Demonstrated analytical and investigative mindset with critical thinking skills and ability to make sound business decisions, and to effectively evaluate and resolve ambiguous, complex and challenging business problems.
  • Strong work ethic, with demonstrated time management and organizational skills.
  • Ability to work in a fast-paced environment at high levels of productivity.
  • Demonstrated ability to negotiate complex settlements.
  • Experience interpreting complex commercial insurance policies and coverage.
  • Ability to manage multiple and shifting priorities in a fast-paced and challenging environment.
  • Knowledge of Microsoft Office Suite and ability to learn business-related software.
  • Demonstrated ability to value diverse opinions and ideas.

Education & Experience

  • Bachelor's Degree or equivalent experience. JD preferred.
  • Typically a minimum six years of relevant experience, preferably in claim handling.
  • Prior negotiation/litigation experience.
  • Must have or be able to obtain and maintain an Insurance Adjuster License within 90 days of hire, where applicable.
  • Professional designations preferred (e.g. CPCU).

#LI-KP1

#LI-Hybrid

In certain jurisdictions, CNA is legally required to include a reasonable estimate of the compensation for this role. In District of Columbia, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois , Maryland, Massachusetts , New York and Washington, the national base pay range for this job level is $72,000 to $141,000 annually. Salary determinations are based on various factors, including but not limited to, relevant work experience, skills, certifications and location. CNA offers a comprehensive and competitive benefits package to help our employees – and their family members – achieve their physical, financial, emotional and social wellbeing goals. For a detailed look at CNA’s benefits, please visit cnabenefits.com.

CNA utilizes AI-enabled technology during the recruiting process. For more information, please visit our careers page .

CNA is committed to providing reasonable accommodations to qualified individuals with disabilities in the recruitment process. To request an accommodation, please contact [email protected]

Posted 2026-08-14

Recommended Jobs

Customer Service Representative - State Farm Agent Team Member

Hemant Jiwnani - State Farm Agent
Jersey City, NJ

Job Description Job Description Benefits: Bonus based on performance Competitive salary Flexible schedule Opportunity for advancement Paid time off Training & development ABO…

View Details
Posted 2026-07-17

Sommelier

River Pointe Inn
Rumson, NJ

Job Description Job Description Benefits: Competitive salary Employee discounts Flexible schedule Opportunity for advancement Training & development Benefits/Perks Flexible S…

View Details
Posted 2026-05-02

Safety Specialist | Construction

Compliance Management International
Linden, NJ

Job Description Job Description Company Summary Compliance Management International (CMI) is a premier global provider of environmental, health, and safety (EHS) services, serving clients of a…

View Details
Posted 2026-07-23

Nurse Case Manager- RN

Elwyn
Vineland, NJ

Job Description Job Description Overview Join a Team That Changes Lives For more than 170 years, Elwyn has been leading the way in supporting children, teens, and adults with autism, inte…

View Details
Posted 2026-08-05

Digital Asset Manager

Robert Half
Park Ridge, NJ

Job Description Job Description We are looking for a detail-oriented Digital Asset Manager to join a food and food processing organization in New Jersey. This Long-term Contract position will foc…

View Details
Posted 2026-07-30

Warehouse Worker Team Lead - Inventory

Dayton, NJ

At Hilti, our warehouse team keeps everything moving. The Warehouse Team Lead provides warehousing, transportation, inventory control, people supervision, work load planning, proficiency and usage…

View Details
Posted 2026-08-15

Private Lacrosse Coach

STXZ LLC
New Providence, NJ

Earn up to $50 per lesson coaching lacrosse on your schedule STXZ is hiring experienced lacrosse coaches to join the nation's #1 private lacrosse training marketplace. You run your own independent…

View Details
Posted 2026-08-14

Caregiver/HHA

Senior Helpers - Madison NJ
Madison, NJ

Job Description Job Description Who We Are: As a leading senior care provider, Senior Helpers is the first national in-home care company to be recognized as a GREAT PLACE TO WORK 3 years in a …

View Details
Posted 2026-07-05

Registered Dental Hygienist

DCS Clinical
Woodbury Heights, NJ

Job Description Job Description Registered Dental Hygienist Location: Woodbury Heights, NJ Position Type: Full-Time or Part-Time Compensation Hourly Rate: $55–$60/hour Annualize…

View Details
Posted 2026-07-17